Those are the facts. Now let’s pull on our really tight crankypants. Entergy is in a race with the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) to see which fleet operator can get into the most trouble with the NRC over NSC issues. We reviewed Entergy’s NSC problems at its different plants in our April 13, 2016 post. Subsequently, the NRC published its report on NSC issues at Entergy’s Arkansas Nuclear One (ANO) plant, which also was subject to an IP 95003 inspection. We reviewed the ANO inspection report on June 16, 2016. That’s all basically bad news. However, there is one bit of good news: Entergy recently offloaded one of its plants, FitzPatrick, to Exelon, a proven nuclear enterprise with a good track record.
Did we mention that Pilgrim is on the industrial equivalent of Death Row? Entergy has announced its plan to shut down the plant on May 31, 2019.** Local anti-nuclear activists want it shut down immediately.*** Pilgrim will certainly be under increased NRC scrutiny for the rest of its operating life. The agency says “Should there be indications of degrading performance, we will take additional regulatory actions as needed, . . . up to and including a plant shutdown order.”**** As readers know, the Safetymatters founders worked in the commercial nuclear industry and are generally supportive of it. But maybe it’s time to pull the plug at Pilgrim.
"Can't anybody here play this game?" — Casey Stengel (1890-1975)
* “NRC to Perform Wide-Ranging Team Inspection at Pilgrim Nuclear Power Plant; Review Supports Agency’s Increased Oversight,” NRC press release No. I-16-030 (Nov. 28, 2016). A.L. Burritt (NRC) to J. Dent (Entergy), “Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station – Notification of Inspection Procedure 95003 Phase ‘C’ Inspection” (Oct. 13, 2016). ADAMS ML16286A592.
** “Entergy Intends to Refuel Pilgrim in 2017; Cease Operations on May 31, 2019” (April 14, 2016). Retrieved Nov. 29, 2016.
*** “Protesters Demand Pilgrim Nuclear Power Plant Be Shut Down Now,” CapeCod.com (Nov. 28, 2016). Retrieved Nov. 29, 2016.
**** “Additional NRC Oversight at Pilgrim Nuclear Power Plant,” an NRC webpage. The quote is under the Assessment Results tab. Retrieved Nov. 29, 2016.