The fallout of these events has not only put into question the future of the Vermont Yankee plant, triggered the interest of the NRC and a requirement that Entergy officials testify under oath, it may also have consequences for Entergy’s plans to spin-off six of its nuclear plants into an independent subsidiary. This restructuring has been a major part of Entergy’s plans for its nuclear business and Entergy has announced that it will be evaluating its options at an upcoming meeting.
There is much to be considered as a result of the Vermont Yankee situation and we will be posting several more times on this subject. In this post we wanted to focus on some initial reaction from other quarters that we found to be off the mark. The link below to the Energy Collective includes a post from Rod Adams who appears to have done a fair bit of analysis of the facts that are currently available. His major observation is as follows:
“That said, it has become clear to me that the corporate leaders at Entergy ....never learned that taking early actions to prevent problems works a hell of a lot better than massive overreaction once it finally becomes apparent to everyone that action is required. Panic at the top never works - it destroys the confidence of the people...”
In part the author relies on the Morgan Lewis law firm’s finding that Entergy employees did not intentionally mislead Vermont regulators. However, he apparently ignores the Morgan Lewis conclusion that Entergy personnel provided responses that were, ultimately, “incomplete and misleading”.
Given the findings of the independent investigator it is hard to see what choice Entergy had, and absent additional facts, it would appear to us that the employee actions were necessary and appropriate. Adams goes on to speculate that there may even be a detrimental effect on the safety culture at the plant - due to the way Entergy is treating its employees. In reality it appears to us that any detrimental impact on safety culture would have been more likely if Entergy had not taken appropriate actions. Still, the question of how safety culture played into the failure of Entergy staff to provide unambiguous information in the first place, and how safety culture will be impacted by subsequent events is a subject that merits more detailed consideration. We will provide our thoughts in future posts.
Link to 2-25-10 Wall Street Journal news item reporting Vermont's action.
Link to Rod Adams 2-26-10 blog post.
Link to 2-24-10 Entergy Press Release on Investigation Report.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Thanks for your comment. We read them all. The moderator will publish comments that are related to our content.